No Shame in Being Materialistic

Home / The Merchant Life Newsletter / No Shame in Being Materialistic

Being materialistic is a great thing.

So ignore what the minimalists tell you.

Allow me to explain.

I get asked this all the time: should brands be design-led or merchant-led? It’s a real debate. Teams fight over it. Org charts get rebuilt around it.

The answer is neither. We should be leading with materials.

Speed to market helps brands get closer to the customer, drive full-price sales, preserve margins, and prevent excess inventory. But that speed doesn’t come from what you bring to market. It comes from how you get there. Specifically, by transforming the relationship between design, merchandising, and materials.

When design leads, the materials team becomes an order taker. A service provider. One global performance brand had material adoption rates of just 20% for color and 35% for textiles. Meaning 80% of new material developments were discarded. Wasted development time, multiple iterations between the vendor and brand, and deadlines getting missed.

When merchandising leads, commercial pressure drives repetitive assortments focused on what sold last season. Category buyers request their own material developments, which causes redundancies and rework.

Both functions bloat the calendar. Faster-to-market becomes a pipe dream.

Now let’s look at a materials-led process:

The materials team researches market trends, visits vendors, and attends trade shows like Premier Vision. They set the season’s Material Direction™️, what’s in the library, what’s in development, and what can be fast-tracked.

Designers design into those materials instead of requesting new ones. New developments are only approved when something doesn’t exist or is a true must-have.

The same goes for merchants. Eliminate new material developments at proto review or after the assortment is locked. Only existing materials can be chosen.

Being materialistic works.

One global brand reduced time to market from 120 weeks to 96 weeks by setting guardrails on how many new materials could be created. Adoption rates climbed to over 60%. The materials team had capacity to innovate instead of scrambling to meet deadlines. Designers had time to spend in the market for inspiration. Merchants spent more time with the customer.

The question was never design vs. merchandising.

It was always: what do we have, what do we need, and how do we get to market without starting from scratch every season?

So go ahead. Be materialistic. I won’t judge you.

– Liza Amlani

Want to go deeper?

Here are a few resources behind this edition.

📖 Our latest book, The Material Life: Process Innovation for Retailers and Brands. Also available on Amazon, Indigo, or your favorite college bookstore.

📄 There’s No Shame in Being ‘Materialistic’ — Sourcing Journal

📄 Fashion’s Most Underrated Opportunity Isn’t Technology. It’s Process. — The Interline


Retail is heading to Nashville for Shoptalk Fall 2026 and so am I!

Joining me on stage will be Kiera Ganann, Chief Merchandising Officer of The Children’s Place, and Jillian Cueff, Chief Merchandising Officer of Claire’s.

Our session title: Holistic Merchandising: Leveraging Org-Wide Data Streams for Better Planning

You’ll hear:

🔸 How merchandising teams sort through the vast troves of data to identify what really matters in terms of trends and shifts in demand.
🔸 The role AI plays in merchandising, and the best ways to leverage it going forward.
🔸 The skillset required to be a successful merchant today.

See you in Nashville!