Direct to Nowhere

Home / The Merchant Life Newsletter / Direct to Nowhere

Direct to Nowhere

For years, DTC was treated like a business model.

Cut out the middleman. Own the customer and data. Sell directly. Grow fast.

But customers don’t shop this way.

They discover a product on social, try it on in a store, buy it through a marketplace, find it at a specialty retailer, or engage with a brand at a cultural event. They don’t see a channel. They see brand.

The brands that endured understood that DTC is a channel, not a strategy. Warby Parker, Glossier, and ON got the message and expanded into wholesale.

Look at Everlane. Radical transparency, a loyal early following, and $145 million raised built a powerful story. But the story wasn’t enough when acquisition costs rose, competitors caught up, and the product assortment stopped standing out. The brand ultimately sold (out) to Shein.

Pure-play DTC asks one channel to do everything: acquire customers, communicate the brand, educate on fit and function, and drive repeat purchases. That’s an expensive proposition, particularly in fashion.

Using the US Open as an example, the brand presence is real. Bought sponsorships are no longer the way in. Brands are creating pop-ups, retail experiences, product launches, athlete partnerships, hospitality and cultural moments across NYC. From Ralph Lauren to Aerie to Chipotle. The customer experience doesn’t stop at the stadium. Winning brands aren’t limiting themselves to one channel. They’re using every touchpoint intentionally.

Stores create connection. Wholesale extends reach. Instagram, TikTok, and WhatNot create discovery. DTC deepens the relationship.

And none of it works if the product assortment doesn’t resonate with the customer. Channel discipline without assortment discipline is just noise. Costly marketing noise.

The future isn’t DTC vs. wholesale. It’s giving each channel a purpose.

– Liza Amlani


I spoke with Glossy about what separated the DTC brands that endured from those that didn’t.

My take: too many brands confused great marketing with a great business. They focused on acquiring customers instead of building trust through their product assortment. They hid operational problems behind a compelling story. And they treated DTC as a strategy when it was always just a channel.

Read the full article in Glossy.