Child’s Play

Early last week, The Children’s Place filed for Chapter 11. Days later came reports that it will liquidate every store.

The news is no surprise. This was TCP’s waiting-to-exhale moment.

When Mithaq Capital took control in 2024, every director but the CEO walked. She was gone within three months, replaced by a board member from finance. This year, Mithaq installed its own managing director as CEO to cut costs.

Again, no retail background.

A real merchant, former Ralph Lauren group president Kim Roy, finally arrived who only lasted four months.

Two lessons emerge here. First, you can’t cost-cut your way back to the customer. And second, throwing money at a problem just gives you a problem with a pile of money on top.

Comps fell almost 17% last quarter. Days before the filing, the remaining leadership stepped down. Because dysfunctional organizations do dysfunctional things.

So even if TCP’s collapse felt inevitable, we wondered if it is a red flag for other adjacent brands in the kids wear category.

The Curious Case of Carter’s

Carter’s sits in the same tier as TCP. As such, we wondered how the brand is poised to perform going forward given the TCP news.

Here is what we find promising:

1. The right hire. While TCP was losing executives, Carter’s landed H&M’s Maria Gemzell as Chief Product Officer (from early 2027). The hire brings H&M’s fast-fashion playbook, including quick inventory turns, trend capture, regional assortments, and the like.

2. New brands driving DTC. Little Planet got its own shop-in-shop at the Atlanta flagship in 2024, and the toddler brand Otter Avenue followed in 2025.

3. A stated pivot. CEO Sharon Price John wants a more consumer-centric, data-driven Carter’s. The Chief Product Officer hire aligns very well with the mission.

4. Cash to fund growth. Carter’s has $1.1 billion in liquidity to invest in growth. When TCP last reported, it had $7 million.

But here are some pressure points:

1. How multiple brands operate. Carter’s runs established names like OshKosh B’gosh and Skip Hop alongside newer launches like Little Planet and Otter Avenue. That risks culture clash, misaligned leadership and duplicated work, and some brands flourish while others lag. We’ve seen it directly with clients.

2. Full-price selling. The brand DNA is strong, but falling birth rates and emerging options like Primark, which is expanding in the US, make full-price selling harder to command. Clearing excess through off-price also poses a devaluation risk.

3. Private label competition. At Target and Walmart, Carter’s sits beside house brands that both retailers have every reason to push. How does the Carter brand avoid fading into the background?

4. Who the marketing speaks to. Carter’s CMO acknowledges that marketing has to evolve. For example, they are now chasing Gen Z parents, who let kids choose their outfits and take cues from social media. But grandparents and older relatives have more spending power and influence, so marketing needs to reach them too.

We also looked at a Carter’s | OshKosh store here in Toronto; we found excellent use of outfitting and options for “occasion dressing.” However, there was quite a bit of promotional activity

Overall, we’re upbeat. Carter’s has the right hires, an open admission that it must evolve, and cash to invest.

Here is what we will be watching for: extent of full-price selling, new brands pulling shoppers into Carter’s own stores, wholesale lines holding their own against private label, and the necessary merchandising discipline. This also means process innovation to keep products on trend.

It’s still early in the game here, Gemzell is arriving in 2027. But as Sharon Price John told CNBC: “Brands evolve. They have to. If they don’t evolve, they’re left behind.”

Meanwhile, TCP is dead on the side of the road, shrinking in the rearview mirror.

— By Raj Dhiman PhD and Liza Amlani