The Theatrical Store

Home / The Merchant Life Newsletter / The Theatrical Store

Theatre is the actor’s creative playground.

It’s a vessel to be big, bold and expressive. Is it any wonder we’re enthralled by Broadway, dazzled by a local production and warmed by the high school spring musical?

Theatre is also a team sport. Stagehands, technical crew, makeup artists and costume designers make the show a reality.

Why talk about theatre? It is quite clear that the need for high-touch has never been greater. We need a human counterpoint to the flood of technology and “slop.”

Stores really are the embodiment of high-touch. But to build a true emotional connection, they need to be thought of with whimsy, not as corporate assets.

Sure, stores are a customer acquisition channel. DTC brands finally realized fundraising and online ads do not a business make. We can talk sales per square foot, smaller formats and balance sheets.

But winning with customers means winning their imagination, which I’d argue is our most underutilized faculty, and one growing duller by the day. And theatre exists to capture the imagination.

We’re not the first to make this connection. In 1999, Pine and Gilmore argued in The Experience Economy that work is theatre and every business a stage.

Although we have our own take on how retailers can make their stores into theatre.

As such, here are our five pillars needed to construct The Theatrical Store.

1 – The Stage. Layout, fixtures, lighting and color all serve one theme. Marketing aligns with merchandising, and the space is neat and tidy.

2 – The Script. What story is being told? What’s the brand’s narrative and point of view? What does the brand stand for?

3 – The Lead Actor. It’s the product. The assortment is the star, not a prop. Think of a cornerstone hero product, compelling outfits and a common thread uniting it all.

4 – The Supporting Cast. Store staff who live and breathe the brand, know the product cold and embody the script. Plus everyone behind the scenes, from the store manager directing the show to the executives who walk the floor. Product creation, merchandising, store planning and marketing must come together to make the show run.

5 – Rehearsal. Everyone plans together, walking through how to showcase the product and bringing the script to life.

When all five are in place, the best part of theatre emerges: improv.

Those spontaneous moments of delight happen precisely because everything else is buttoned up. Trying to engineer these moments is fine, but the spur of the moment substance is what customers will gush about.

And with a solid foundation, improv is also how you recover gracefully when something goes sideways.

Liza went on her own theatre-hopping experience during her time in NYC last week. She found lots of theatrical gems and reports back on these three standout examples:

1 – Sabyasachi, Christopher Street

In one word, opulent. Vogue has asked whether it could be India’s first global luxury house, and it’s clear why. The store is couture up close. Associates encouraged us to take photos, try things on and linger. Nothing was gatekept, and everyone on the floor was visibly proud to be there, giving browsers the same energy as buyers. That’s a brand decision, and it’s working: a single Bergdorf Goodman event moved over $1 million in product in one day.

2 – Buck Mason, Broadway

The vintage Porsche in a corner window was the pull to enter. I’d been to the LA and SoHo stores, but this one felt different: high ceilings, open and airy, even with props and product throughout. The car, the bookshelves and carefully chosen objects signal exactly who wears the brand. Their best-selling tees are made in the US, from knitting mill to finished shirt. This nails the lead actor and the script pillars.

3 – Tuckernuck, Upper East Side

I’ve followed this one for a while. It started as an online marketplace, built a cult following and launched private brands to complement its assortment. Now the digital darling is a chic, curated store designed to feel like a private Upper East Side apartment, with distinct rooms and a natural flow from one to the next. The highlight: the fitting rooms. A hidden pass-through cabinet lets associates drop off a new size from outside, so you never have to peek out half-dressed to ask for help. The stage components shine here.

It’s easy to think a store needs big budgets and grand gestures to become theatre.

That couldn’t be further from the truth.

A local theatre company’s Hamlet can be riveting. The thrill of the off-price hunt has its own dramatic flair. A one-person show in the town square can go viral. So can a TikTok channel selling secondhand clothes.

Think of any category, tier or channel of retail. All of them can capture the imagination.

It just takes the conscious choice to make it so, and the five pillars give any retailer a way to get there.

How lucky we are that the spotlight has room for everyone.

— By Raj Dhiman PhD and Liza Amlani